Team of Rivals '08?

As I previously argued, Secretary of Health and Human Services seems like a logical consolation prize for Barack Obama to offer Hillary Clinton:

There is, however, one cabinet position for which Clinton seems both well-qualified and well-suited: Secretary of Health and Human Services. As a member of the Senate's Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions since 2001, she is familiar with many of the issues dealt with by the Department of Health and Human Services. Given her intense and long-standing advocacy on behalf of health care reform and children's issues in particular, this seems an ideal appointment for her. Whether she would prefer it to being a senator, however, is anyone's guess.

 It now looks like Obama and his advisers may have come to the same conclusion.

According to The Daily Telegraph,

Senior figures in the Obama camp have told Democrat colleagues that the offer to Mrs Clinton of a cabinet post as health secretary or to steer new legislation through the Senate will be a central element of their peace overtures to the New York senator...

Another Democrat who has discussed strategy with friends in the Obama inner circle said that Mr Obama was openly considering asking Mrs Clinton to join his cabinet, alongside two other former presidential rivals: John Edwards, who is seen as a likely attorney general; and Joe Biden, who is a leading contender to become Secretary of State.

To my knowledge, this is the first time anyone associated with the Obama campaign has floated the idea of Secretary Clinton.

Two weeks ago, Obama explained why he might make such an offer. At a town hall in Florida, he was asked if he would consider an unspecified person as a running mate, "even if his or her spouse is an occasional pain in the butt." After laughing and pointing out that the primary campaign wasn't over yet, Obama answered in more detail:

I'm a practical guy. One of my heroes is Abraham Lincoln. A while back, there was a wonderful book written by Doris Kearns Goodwin called "Team of Rivals," in which she talked about how Lincoln basically pulled all the people he'd been running against into his Cabinet. Because whatever personal feelings there were, the issue was, "How can we get the country through this time of crisis?" I think that has to be the approach one takes to the vice president and the Cabinet.

Andrew Sullivan, a rabid Clinton-hater, had previously raised the possibility of a "Hate-Filled Dream Ticket" by referencing Goodwin's book and noting (begrudgingly) that giving Clinton a prominent role in the Obama administration could bolster, not detract, from his message of unity:

His model should be Abraham Lincoln. What Lincoln did, as Doris Kearns Goodwin explained in her brilliant book, "Team of Rivals," was to bring his most bitter opponents into his cabinet in order to maintain national and party unity at a time of crisis. Obama - who is a green legislator from Illinois, just as Lincoln was - could signal to his own supporters in picking Clinton that he isn't capitulating to old politics, he is demonstrating his capacity to reach out and engage and co-opt his rivals and opponents. Done deftly, picking Clinton could even resonate with Obama's supporters as a statesmanlike gesture, a sign of the kind of reconciliation he wants for his own party for the fall. It is consonant with his core message: that he can unfiy the country in a way few other politicians can. It would even help heal the gulf that has opened up between the Clintons and black voters in this campaign. It's win-win all round.

Notably, Lincoln's Team of Rivals was not an effort to bring the entire country together, but rather to mend the rifts within his own party at a time when it was greatly divided - his Cabinet did not include any of his opponents in the general election: John Bell, John Breckenridge, and Stephen Douglas. (Fortunately for him, Lincoln never had to deal with the religion of "High Broderism" and its zealous, misguided calls for bipartisanship.)

Every one of Lincoln's rivals for the Republican presidential nomination, however, was drafted into his Cabinet. Pennsylvania Senator Simon Cameron became Lincoln's Secretary of War, New York Senator William Seward became Lincoln's Secretary of State, Ohio Governor Salmon Chase became Lincoln's Treasury Secretary (and was later nominated by Lincoln to be Chief Justice of the Supreme Court), and Edward Bates became Lincoln's Attorney General.

A century later, Lyndon Johnson eloquently explained why co-opting your adversaries in this manner made eminent political sense. When asked why he kept J. Edgar Hoover in charge of the FBI, Johnson told the NY Times that "It's probably better to have him inside the tent pissing out, than outside the tent pissing in."

Cross-posted at Intellectual Carpet Bombing 



Display:


Re: Team of Rivals '08? (none / 0)

The Lincoln analogy is good, but it's worth noting he never chose one of his rivals to be VP.


by IncognitoErgoSum on Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 02:58:34 PM EST

Re: Team of Rivals '08? (none / 0)

Having Seward as VP would probably have lead to an earlier demise for Lincoln.  Salmon Chase wasn't trustworthy.

The others weren't really qualified.


by Reaper0Bot0 on Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 03:02:22 PM EST
[ Parent ]

the british papers getting the scoop? suspect. (none / 0)


"Democracy! Bah! When I hear that I reach for my feather Boa!" Allen Ginsberg
by canadian gal on Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 02:59:34 PM EST

Re: the british papers getting the scoop? suspect. (none / 0)

The UK papers are always 2 steps ahead of our media.


by neonplaque on Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 03:01:40 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Team of Rivals '08? (2.00 / 1)

Not gonna happen. Clinton is not going to leave the Senate for a cabinet position. She can get more done in the Senate. She will only leave that job to be President or President of the Senate.


by LakersFan on Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 03:02:20 PM EST

Re: Team of Rivals '08? (none / 0)

Yeah, I agree. Wouldn't this be a demotion? Plus, what would she do at the end of the presidency? I don't think it would be terribly easy to go back to NY and ask to be their senator again. If she didn't win the nomination that year she would be stuck in Edwards land, and I don't think that suits her talents very well.


John McCain wants to make abortion illegal
by Lost Thought on Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 03:10:00 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Team of Rivals '08? (none / 0)

The team of rivals analogy as set forth in this diary makes no sense. Lincoln had many rivals when in actuality Obama has only one real rival, Hillary Clinton. It thus made sense for lincoln to distibute cabinet posts among his rivals, it doesn't for Obama. There is also no point in wiping out long held senate seats for cabinet posts. This would hardly be a good mechanism for change.

The only team of rivals analogy that fits the present scenario is one where Hillary is offered the VP post. This brings immediate unity to the team. An offer of a cabinet post does not accomplish that purpose. What this ticket needs is unity, and that is what this party needs. It's going to be a rough road ahead. To attempt to cross it without unity is a needless risk to say the least.


The man who reads nothing at all is better educated than the man who reads nothing but newspapers. -- Thomas Jefferson
by pollbuster on Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 03:26:40 PM EST

Re: Team of Rivals '08? (none / 0)

great diary ~ recommended.

i've long seen similarities btwn Barack and Lincoln ('rookie' legislators, against wars of imperialism, from Illinois (kinda), tall ;) ) ~

i could really see BHO putting together a cabinet from all over the spectrum in some ways.

however, iirc, lincoln's cabinet meetings were ridiculous, even more rancorous than washington's were supposed to've been.


by pholkhero on Tue Jun 03, 2008 at 03:52:13 PM EST


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.